If I have to find the volume, what are the things I would need. eg., If it is cylindrical, I would measure length and diameter. But, it is irregularly shaped. Like the above rock.

Where should I start? Couple of google search says something related to integration and contours. Somebody pls give me some handle :) I would say i"m very beginner level in beer-selection.com.

You are watching: What is the volume of the rock

Many Thanks :)

Edit:60 to 70% accuracy would be helpful.

*
*


integration contour-integration
Share
Cite
Follow
edited Jul 31 "12 at 15:12
Prince Ashitaka
asked Jul 31 "12 at 14:08
*

Prince AshitakaPrince Ashitaka
16311 gold badge11 silver badge66 bronze badges
$\endgroup$
10
| Show 5 more comments

4 Answers 4


Active Oldest Votes
8
$\begingroup$
As your comment indicates, you"re not interested in rocks so much as tumors.

One possible approach is to use a tomographic technique. Many medical imaging tools image the body using tomography: that is, examining the body one "slice" at a time.

If you have access to such tools, or can derive such an example, then what you want to do is cut the rock/tumor into many slices along some axis, and then compute the area of the tumor at that slice. This is a bit easier to do that doing it in three dimensions.

Then, you move forward by some $\Delta z$ along the $z$-axis (or whatever axis), and repeat.

Multiply each surface area by $\Delta z$, sum them, and you will get a good estimate. The estimate is better the smaller your $\Delta z$.

To compute the area of each "slice", you can do many things: fit a simpler shape to the data, perform Monte Carlo integration, or decompose the shape into a series of piecewise linear segments.


Share
Cite
Follow
answered Jul 31 "12 at 16:27
*

EmilyEmily
33.7k55 gold badges8484 silver badges131131 bronze badges
$\endgroup$
3
Add a comment |
5
$\begingroup$
The easiest way (if you have a 3d model) is simple Monte Carlo integration. One builds a big bounding box around the "rock", and then randomly chooses a large number of points inside the box. The ratio of points inside the "rock" to the the number of total points, is the ratio of volumes. Since you can easily calculate the box"s volume, you now also know the volume of the rock.

The task of finding whether or not a point is inside the rock is in general complex, but is simplified if you can assume that the rock is convex. In that case, you test each triangle that belongs to your 3D mesh: if the point is in the right side for all triangles, the point is inside.


Share
Cite
Follow
edited May 30 "15 at 16:28
answered Jul 31 "12 at 14:41
*

nbubisnbubis
31.3k77 gold badges6868 silver badges130130 bronze badges
$\endgroup$
1
Add a comment |
3
$\begingroup$
There is a very simple and elegant algorithm for calculating the volume of an arbitrary, closed mesh described in this paper (Zhang, Cha, and Tsuhan Chen. "Efficient feature extraction for 2D/3D objects in mesh representation." Image Processing, 2001. Proceedings. 2001 International Conference on. Vol. 3. IEEE, 2001. Page 2). The trick is to base a tetrahedron on each triangle and top it off at the origin and then sum up all volumes, signed by whether the triangle faces the origin.


Share
Cite
Follow
edited Oct 16 "13 at 13:33
answered Sep 16 "13 at 22:34
*

Lenar HoytLenar Hoyt
92299 silver badges1818 bronze badges
$\endgroup$
Add a comment |
0
$\begingroup$
If you don"t want to use Archimedes" solution, and you know the material, you can look up the density and weigh the rock.

See more: Chevy Astro Van Miles Per Gallon, Gas Mileage Of 2000 Chevrolet Astro


Share
Cite
Follow
answered Jul 31 "12 at 14:21
*

wesleywesley
11233 bronze badges
$\endgroup$
Add a comment |
Highly active question. Earn 10 reputation (not counting the association bonus) in order to answer this question. The reputation requirement helps protect this question from spam and non-answer activity.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged integration contour-integration or ask your own question.


The Overflow Blog
Featured on Meta
Linked
2
How to calculate the area of bizarre shapes
Related
4
Finding the volume of water in a swimming pool
0
Shared Volumes of Rotation around an Axis
2
How to get the trace surface of an n-gon rotated around a central point with constant orientation (integral)
6
Articles on the "Property I found" and other types of Centers (excluding the Centroid)?
0
Find a function of depth with respect to time when filling a cone
2
Integrating $\sin(\sqrt{16-x^2})$ with respect to x
Hot Network Questions more hot questions
Question feed
Subscribe to RSS
Question feed To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader.


beer-selection.comematics
Company
Stack Exchange Network
site design / logo © 2021 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. rev2021.10.1.40358


beer-selection.comematics Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled
*

Your privacy

By clicking “Accept all cookies”, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy.