One criticism that the ‘Twilight’ collection I find so tired is the the creating is bad. Is the really? come me, composing in a publication is secondary to storytelling and also my enjoyment that a narrative. I only notification poor composing if it’s really obvious and also glaring. Do human being really read books to watch syntax and also punctuation? I recognize I don’t, as I uncover these to be complementary accessories to the story in question. Lot of of publications have “worse” creating than ‘Twilight’ or the on par with Meyer’s prose. Yet, they acquire nowhere near the criticism. I discover this criticism tiring since it almost feels like people internalize well-known knocks versus the collection and just say the creating is bad even though it may not be, when on the other hand they gain other publications that no much better from the standpoint? Idk, simply my thoughts.

You are watching: Examples of bad writing in twilight


6 comments
share
save
hide
report
91% Upvoted
This object is archived
New comments can not be posted and votes cannot be cast
Sort by: best


*

level 1
· 1y
I think few of the concern is the people came to twilight for fantasy as soon as it was primarily romance. Most authors have actually their own styles and also such, but the different genres seem to have actually a larger space in word choice and other small but far-ranging things prefer that. So once you have fantasy persons unknowingly jumping right into romance, particularly when the book series is getting contrasted to another best selling fantasy series (Harry Potter).

Now, exactly how Meyer compare to various other romance authors, i dont know. Yet that is wherein the more comprehensive comparison and also 'she writes poor comes from. She writes differently than to be expected and it spiraled from there.


11
Share
ReportSave
level 1
· 1y

That’s constantly confused me too! people have accused Meyer of having actually purple prose, yet she no go almost everywhere near that level that annoying detail or thesaurus-y words; i remember this one testimonial (can’t remember by who) that stated she wrote with “luminous clarity”, and I’ve constantly agreed with that assessment. I favor her writing since it never gets in the means of what’s happening.

And yes, people definitely do internalize the Twilight vitriol. Most of them have actually never also read a single page of it however still feel justified come spout off every kinds the hatred about it.


10
Share
ReportSave
level 1
· 1y
Aro did nothing wrong

I uncover that people who internalize others' objections of the series tend come say the publications are OK yet nothing special after reading it for themselves.

Is her writing bad? Depends.

On a technological level, sure. The bulk of commas space unnecessary. Most of the conversation tags don't add anything the isn't currently obvious due to the fact that of the wording or context of what's being spoken. She sometimes uses the thesaurus also much and misuses words. There space some boy and major math, science, and geography errors. Breaking Dawn is among the bigger offenders of the last few points, despite that may not be she fault as I'm open minded not certain if it was properly edited.

Despite this, the prose is very easy come read and the tone and also descriptions make it easy to feel what she wants you to. This flaws don't hurt immersion if you make an honest effort to skip them.

On a structure level, not as bad as it seems. As others have actually mentioned, if you go into Twilight expecting a fantasy story rather of a romance v a fantasy flavor girlfriend won't gain what you're trying to find in regards to tropes.

If friend tried to make a plot pyramid for each book you'd gain a heart-rate monitor v a spike in ~ the finish (mostly in the an initial two books). Twilight and also New Moon have actually been defined as "many little plots pretending to it is in a huge plot" and "no plot at all pretending to it is in a large plot," respectively. Those explanation aren't entirely wrong, however that's no really the poor thing it's made the end to be. Emotions space SMeyer's solid points, not her plotting and it doesn't impede the books' emotional impacts.

The story is second to the characters and their interactions, the climaxes the Twilight and also New Moon absence buildup however they space extreme instances of your books' main problems (interacting v the vampire world is dangerous for Bella and Edward's negative decision making, respectively) therefore they're not entirely out that place. This renders the books hard to it is adapted into movies as over there are plenty of scenes that deserve to be eliminated without affect the climax yet those themes are an ext important come the story and also the readers' experience than stated climaxes. Twilight's framework is more like a soap opera 보다 a drama series.

See more: Why Can'T You Microwave Mcdonalds Coffee Cups, Can You Microwave Mcdonald'S Coffee Cups

Twilight's writing is flawed but not in a means that would certainly hurt its audience's experience reading it. SMeyer's staminas lie in various other areas.